Learning goal: Investigate three fictional energy failures, compare measured evidence, test one controlled change, and explain the outcome using watts (W) for power and watt-hours (Wh) for energy.
For: approximately ages 11+, with adult support where helpful. Prerequisites: basic multiplication and the idea that 1 Wh = 1 W sustained for one hour. Time: 15–20 minutes per case, or 45–60 minutes for all three.
Preparation: Open each linked case in a browser, provide a way to record readings, and print one worksheet per learner if desired. Students can work without accounts or personal data. Equipment and readings are fictional and are not installation or electrical safety advice.
Investigation worksheet
Use the same five steps for every case: predict the cause → collect evidence → test one change → explain the result → reflect on a new situation. Record the units beside every number.
Remember: Power is measured in W; energy used over time is measured in Wh. For constant power, energy (Wh) = power (W) × time (hours).
Case 1: The Overnight Drain
Mission: Keep the refrigerator running for the full 18:00–06:00 night.
1. Prediction: What do you think caused the failure? Why?
2. Evidence: Find two useful clues in the game. Give each reading a name, number and unit. If the clue is non-numerical, state the observation.
| Clue / measurement | Reading | Unit (W, Wh, h, V, etc.) |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | ||
| 2. |
3. Experiment: Run the original system. Change only one option and run it again. What changed?
| Test | Result / measurement | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Original | ||
| One change: __________ |
4. Explanation: Did your change meet the mission? Explain using your two readings and the difference between W and Wh.
5. Reflection: A replacement inverter draws 10 W of overhead for 24 hours. How much energy does overhead alone use? Give your reasoning, not just your selected answer.
Case 2: Full Battery, Cold Kettle
Mission: Deliver 75 Wh of kettle heating within five minutes while retaining 100 W background service.
1. Prediction: What do you think caused the failure? Why?
2. Evidence: Find two useful clues in the game. Give each reading a name, number and unit. If the clue is non-numerical, state the observation.
| Clue / measurement | Reading | Unit (W, Wh, h, V, etc.) |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | ||
| 2. |
3. Experiment: Run the original system. Change only one option and run it again. What changed?
| Test | Result / measurement | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Original | ||
| One change: __________ |
4. Explanation: Did your change meet the mission? Explain using your two readings and the difference between W and Wh.
5. Reflection: Will the 900 W kettle fit if the background load rises from 100 W to 200 W? Give your reasoning, not just your selected answer.
Case 3: The Misleading Battery Label
Mission: Supply 120 W of AC cabin service for 12 hours using a compatible battery/inverter preset.
1. Prediction: What do you think caused the failure? Why?
2. Evidence: Find two useful clues in the game. Give each reading a name, number and unit. If the clue is non-numerical, state the observation.
| Clue / measurement | Reading | Unit (W, Wh, h, V, etc.) |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | ||
| 2. |
3. Experiment: Run the original system. Change only one option and run it again. What changed?
| Test | Result / measurement | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Original | ||
| One change: __________ |
4. Explanation: Did your change meet the mission? Explain using your two readings and the difference between W and Wh.
5. Reflection: How do 25.6 V × 100 Ah and 12.8 V × 200 Ah compare? Give your reasoning, not just your selected answer.
Facilitator notes — excluded from student print
Learning objectives: distinguish battery-side and AC-side watts, identify a power limit independently of stored Wh, and convert voltage × amp-hours into nominal Wh before applying a usable fraction. Students should support each claim with a recorded clue and a controlled experiment, not with guessing.
Discussion prompts: Which reading directly rules out your first prediction? Did the tested change affect power, energy, or both? Did an improvement preserve every required load? What would need to be measured differently for real equipment?
Overnight Drain: The original battery-side draw is 45 W ÷ 0.9 + 50 W = 100 W. Starting from 1,000 Wh, the system reaches cutoff after 10 hours (04:00 from 18:00). Changing only inverter overhead to 10 W yields 60 W battery-side; 12 hours uses 720 Wh and leaves 280 Wh. Merely increasing uncharged capacity does not add available energy. Reflection: 10 W for 24 hours is 240 Wh.
Full Battery, Cold Kettle: The original 1,500 W kettle plus 100 W background load requests 1,600 W, exceeding the 1,000 W continuous AC ceiling even though battery energy is available. Either a 2,000 W continuous inverter or a 900 W kettle for five minutes supplies the fictional 75 Wh heating target with the background load. Adding storage alone cannot overcome the inverter power limit. Reflection: 900 W + 200 W = 1,100 W still fails the 1,000 W limit.
Misleading Battery Label: System A offers 12.8 V × 100 Ah × 0.8 = 1,024 Wh usable; system B offers 25.6 V × 100 Ah × 0.8 = 2,048 Wh usable. At 120 W AC and 90% conversion efficiency, required battery-side power is about 133.33 W: A lasts 7.68 hours and B serves 12 hours with 448 Wh remaining. The presets are complete compatible systems, not interchangeable drop-in batteries. Reflection: 25.6 V × 100 Ah and 12.8 V × 200 Ah both store 2,560 Wh nominally.
Interpreting results: Ask learners to separate watts (instantaneous rate), watt-hours (accumulated energy) and inverter efficiency (a conversion ratio). Verify that the repaired experiment actually meets the case's stated service objective; not every higher-capacity or lower-power option is a valid repair.
Model boundaries: These answers describe the fixed values and interventions in the three authored DETECTIVE_CASES, not actual appliance duty cycles, battery cutoffs, inverter surge behavior or certified electrical design. The score is a classroom prompt, not standardized assessment. No names or recordings are needed.
Progress and replay: local progress stays browser-specific. Correct answers must actually be submitted; old incomplete awards cannot be invented. Clearing Detective progress does not clear Renewable Energy City. Reviewing an earlier failed run does not erase an already completed case; the numeric table and scenario-relative replay describe the selected run.